Maplewood History: George Shields and his Maplewood Subdivision

The age we live in is simultaneously fascinating and terrifying.  There is no clear indicator as to whether our technological advances will save or sink us.  Wonderful tool that it can be, the internet is both a boon and a curse. There is plenty written every day about the curse side of it.  This post is about the boon.

The boon in this instance is my internet subscription to Newspapers.com.  From this I was able to learn some very interesting details about my neighborhood.  It is identified as Shields Subdivision on the Maplewood map in the 1909 Plat book of St. Louis county. That is all I knew about it.  The boundaries are Big Bend on the west, Sutton on the east, Elm on the north and the railroad tracks on the south. The only streets other than those just mentioned are James, Walter and Edgar.  Just who were those guys?

Newspapers.com was able to provide some very interesting details which you are about to see. Try to imagine the impossibility of obtaining this kind of information just a few years ago.

Home, sweet home to me. From the 1909 Plat Book of St. Louis County.

What a find this little article was! From the Friday, December 19th edition of the St. Louis Post-Dispatch. The year? 1890!  The tract George Shields bought was 25 acres.  He paid J.P. Thomas, brother of W.L. Thomas, ten times the amount he paid for it just five years earlier.  It was adjacent to the “cozy” MoPac station.  Maplewood the city did not exist until 1908.  The Maplewood referred to in this article is the original Maplewood Subdivision bounded by Sutton on the west, Marshall on the east, Manchester on the north, and Flora on the south.

Our cozy little depot in 1885. The location can be seen on the first image of this post. Courtesy of the Terminal Railroad Association of St. Louis. Historical and Technical Society, Inc. Issue 30. Summer 1994.

A real estate transaction by George Shields and his wife Margaret R. The St. Louis Globe-Democrat Dec. 22,1887.  I have not found any record of a middle initial for our George.  There is another prominent George Shields , a military man, that shows up in my searches.

A man named James Shields managed to get himself in the papers several times during my period of interest. Remember the street names in my neighborhood, Walter, Edgar and James.  The St. Louis Post-Dispatch, August 26, 1884.

James makes the paper again. The St. Louis Post-Dispatch, Sept. 15, 1890.

James again. This time from The St. Louis Post-Dispatch on Sept. 13, 1900.  He is definitely an interesting character but so far I don’t know if he is who our street, James, was named after.

George dies on May 4, 1891. From this we get quite a bit of information.  He came from Nashville to St. Louis in 1896.  His home was at Delmar and Cabanne.  The St. Louis Post-Dispatch.

I remember an old saying. Something like when a man dies he kicks the dust. George certainly did. He died on May 4th. This ad appeared in The St. Louis Post-Dispatch on the 10th.  Nice place.  The family must have decided they’d rather have the money.  It is hard to divide up a mansion amongst the family.  But who were the rest of the family?

Here it is folks. This is the reward to me for a lot of searching. This is my neighborhood.  B.F. Shields was one of George’s and Margaret’s sons.  This ad appeared in The St. Louis Post-Dispatch on May 17, 1891.  George had only been gone 13 days.  Things were moving pretty fast, don’t you think?  Apparently the property had already been subdivided but none of the lots had been sold.

Here is the ad again on My 24th. Now we are “The cream of all residence lots between Kirkwood and St. Louis.” I always knew we were special.

The man had a lot of property. He laid out Clifton Heights as well. That’s a very charming real estate development.  If you are not familiar with it, the centerpiece is a small lake situated in the middle of a little park with some of the homes surrounding it.  The beauty of the setting makes it very desirable property these days.  This ad was in The St. Louis Post-Dispatch on June 15, 1891.  One of the auctioneers was Henry Sutton, son of two of Maplewood’s earliest settlers, James and Ann Sutton.

Apparently the mansion didn’t sell at the auction. This notice in the St. Louis Post-Dispatch on July 19, 1891 indicates it was sold privately for $500 more than the highest bid at the auction. $14,000 in 1891 would be worth about $386,000 today.

This article appeared in the St. Louis Globe-Democrat on June 29, 1905.  Here we learn that B.F. Shields is the son of George and Margaret R.  They also have two children both named after each of them, Margaret and George.  Then, I guess, when Margaret marries and George arrives at the age of maturity the estate will be equally divided between the following children (all theirs?), Mrs. Georgia Hopkins (a married daughter?), B.F.,  Albert C., Walter, Margaret, George and Edgar.  Seven children in all.  I feel fairly certain that the streets, Walter and Edgar, in my neighborhood were named for those two of their children.  But what about James?  There is no James among them.  Surely the criminal, James Shields, is not of their family.  I have found no connection.  What say you, Ancestry.com subscribers?

Daughter Margaret, “still quite young” married Charles Kohl from Chicago two years after her mother passed.  The St. Louis Post-Dispatch, Oct. 8, 1907.

Things did not go well for B.F. Shields. I have not found in any of the articles what names the B and F stood for.

From The St. Louis Post-Dispatch, July 16, 1909. This is a hell of a note to end on so I won’t.

I’ll go out with this article which ran in The St. Louis Post-Dispatch, Sept. 30, 1933.

 

That’s a lot of reading, I know.  I wonder how many of you will get through it.  Believe it or not there are quite a few articles that I didn’t include.  Be thankful for that.

I received quite a few interesting comments on the 1970s era photographs that ran in the last few posts.  Much thanks to all of you who took the time to chime in.  I certainly learned a lot.

Summer is fading.  Soon we’ll be into the holiday season.  At this time of year I usually think of a favorite Dave Barry quote which I couldn’t find so I’ll say it from memory.  I know from the decorated pine trees, the colored lights, fake snow and tinsel that very soon it will be…Halloween.  Apologies to Dave.  If anyone knows that quote send it to me.  His is much better than my rendition.

‘Til next time,

Doug

7 thoughts on “Maplewood History: George Shields and his Maplewood Subdivision

  1. This from Esley Hamilton by email: Doug, I loved your article today, quite a shock at the end. I made a comment online and subsequently have been doing some more digging. I looked up every subdivision named “Shields” in the plat index at the recorder of deeds, and I found that the reason I couldn’t find it before is that there are two that are indexed only as “Shields.” The earlier one, April 9, 1890 (Book 1, page 94) turns out to be Shields Subdivision in the Town of Kirkwood, owned by Mr. George Shield. The second one, platted June 10, 1891 (Book 4, page 20), is Shield’s Sub-Division of Part of Lot 9, Subdivision of J. C. Sutton’s Estate, U. S. Survey 2037. The surprise is that the owner is Jeptha H. Simpson. His name also appears in connection with the Ferguson property. Shelds’ and Ashby Addition to Ferguson was platted Nov. 13, 1890 by two couples, George Shields & Margaret R. Shields and W. W. Ashby & M. Octavia Ashby. Shields & Ashby Second Addition to Ferguson followed June 9, 1891 (Book 1, page 105), but it was owned only by Jeptha H. Simpson and M. Octavia Ashby, although W. W. Ashby also visited the notary with them.
    The other subdivision I found was Shields’ Barracks Subdivision, April 17, 1899 (Book 5, page 41), owned by B. F. Shields. It was somewhere in the Lemay area (Carondelet Suburbs).
    I looked for probate records for George. The state index has his name and date but apparently no inventory or receipts, etc., at least not in City records.
    Cheers,

    Esley

  2. So much for the “good old days”. Real estate scammers, knife fights, folks dying of poison.
    Interesting history of Maplewood that is for sure.

  3. These days Delmar and Cabanne are parallel streets that don’t cross. 3805 Delmar would be in the front yard of Cardinal Ritter High School on Spring Ave., just west of Grand Center. Sure enough, my index to St. Louis City Ordinances shows that a street named Cabanne running between Chippewa and Bell Avenues was changed to Spring by ordinance number 17,121. That stretch of Delmar is now Grandel Square. Before the streets were closed and houses demolished for the high school, quite a few houses from the 1880s were still standing on that site, and I wish somebody had taken pictures of them before they were cleared.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *